Simple Truths About Why Nice Guys Struggle with Women
Last October a young man named Eric helped Tom put the storm windows up. He works at the hardware store in town and he is the…

Last October a young man named Eric helped Tom put the storm windows up. He works at the hardware store in town and he is the kind of young man who carries your bags to the car without being asked. He stayed for supper that first night because I made too much chili. Then he stayed for supper most Thursdays after that. Tom likes him. I like him. He is polite and funny and he does the dishes without being told.
He is also, by his own account, a complete failure with women. He told us this over pie one night, half laughing and half not. He said he does everything right. He is nice. He listens. He remembers birthdays. And every woman he likes ends up calling him a sweetheart and then dating somebody else.
I have been married to Tom for more than thirty years. I raised three kids and watched all of them date. I have listened to a lot of friends talk about the men they chose and the men they passed over. So I started paying attention to what Eric told us. I also asked the readers of this blog what they thought. Here is what I came up with, one supper at a time.
Nice is not the same as kind

The first thing I noticed about Eric was how often he said yes. He said yes to a second helping he did not want. He said yes when Tom asked if he liked a ball game he clearly had no interest in. He said yes to staying late and then looked at his watch for an hour.
I asked him about it one night. He said he did not want to make a fuss. I told him that going along with everything is not kindness. Kindness takes some effort. It means paying attention to what a person actually needs. Going along is just avoiding trouble.
A reader named Pamela R., 57, from Lexington, Kentucky, wrote me something I keep thinking about. She said she dated a man who agreed with everything she said for six months and she never once felt like he had actually heard her. She said it was like talking to a mirror.
Being agreeable is a way of hiding. Being kind is a way of showing up.
He never says what he wants

Eric told us about a woman from his church. He liked her. He had liked her for most of a year. I asked him what he had done about it. He said he had sat near her at the potluck.
Tom put his fork down. He said that in thirty-some years he had never once seen a woman fall in love with a man because of where he sat.
Eric said he was waiting for the right moment. I told him I had heard that from a lot of men and it usually meant they were scared of the answer. That is fair. The answer might be no. But a woman cannot say yes to a question nobody asked.
I will tell you how Tom asked me out. He walked up and said he wanted to take me to dinner on Friday and asked if I was free. That was it. No speech. It worked because it was clear.
A woman cannot read a man’s mind, and most of them have stopped trying.
He puts her on a shelf

When Eric talks about the women he likes, he talks like they are made of glass. Everything she does is perfect. Everything she says is wise. He described one young woman to me and I honestly could not picture a real person.
I told him he was describing a saint, not a girlfriend. Real women spill coffee. Real women get cranky before lunch. If you put a woman up on a shelf you cannot reach her, and worse, she can feel it. She knows you are not seeing her. You are seeing an idea.
My middle one dated someone like this for a few months. The young man was lovely. But my child told me it was exhausting to be admired all the time. There was no room to have a bad day.
A woman wants to be seen, not worshipped.
He does favors and keeps score
Eric fixed a woman’s porch light. Then he helped her move a couch. Then he drove her to the airport at five in the morning. He told us all this with a tone I recognized. It was the tone of a man who had been putting money in a machine and expecting it to pay out.
I said it gently. I asked if he would have done those things for her if there was no chance of dating her. He thought about it for a while. He said probably not all of them.
That is the problem. A favor with a hook in it is not a favor. Women can tell. They might not say so, but they can feel the weight of it. And when the payout does not come, the man feels cheated and the woman feels tricked.
Tom has done a thousand things for me over the years. He has never once brought up the list.
Help should be free or it should not be offered.
He apologizes for taking up space

One Thursday Eric bumped the table and said sorry. He reached past Tom for the salt and said sorry. He told a story that ran a little long and ended it with sorry.
I counted. He said it eleven times before dessert.
I asked him about it. He said he did not want to be a bother. I told him that a man who is always apologizing for existing makes the people around him tired. It puts the other person in charge of reassuring him. That is work. A woman on a first date does not want a job.
A reader named Joyce W., 63, from Cedar Rapids, Iowa, said her second husband never apologized for things that did not need apologizing for. She said it was one of the first things she noticed about him. She said it made her feel like she could relax.
Standing in a room without apology is not arrogance. It is just standing.
He has no life of his own

I asked Eric what he did on the weekends. He said it depended on who was free. I asked what he did when nobody was free. He said he mostly waited around to see if somebody would text.
Tom said that sounded like a dog by the door. He was not being mean. He meant it the way an old friend means it.
A man with nothing going on is a man with nothing to share. He has no stories. He has no plans she could join. He is just available, and being available all the time is not as attractive as men think it is. It reads as empty.
When Tom and I were dating he played softball on Tuesdays and he did not cancel it for me. I liked that. It told me he had a shape to his life before I got there.
A full life is the best thing a man can bring to a date.
He treats friendship like a waiting room

Eric has a lot of women friends. He is proud of this. But when I listened closer, most of them were women he had liked at some point and then settled for being friends with. He was still hoping. He was still hanging around in case something changed.
I told him that is not friendship. That is a waiting room. And the women in it can tell. They might enjoy his company and still feel a little uneasy, because something is being held back.
Our oldest told me years ago about a friend who finally admitted he had been in love with her for two years. She felt awful. Not because he loved her, but because she realized the whole friendship had been a performance on his side.
A friend is a friend or he is not. A woman deserves to know which one she has.
He cannot handle a no

Eric told us about a woman who turned him down for coffee. He said it was fine. Then he told the story three more times over the next hour. He kept going back to it like a sore tooth.
I asked what he had said when she told him no. He said he had asked if she was sure. Then he asked if maybe another week would be better. Then he sent a long message explaining himself.
Tom winced. I winced.
A no is a complete answer. It does not need a follow-up. A man who argues with a no, or sulks about it, or tries to negotiate it, makes every woman who hears about it a little more careful around him. And they do hear about it. Women talk.
A reader named Teresa B., 51, from Albuquerque, New Mexico, wrote that the most attractive thing a man ever did was say “no problem, good to see you” when she turned him down. She said she thought about him for a week after that.
The way a man takes a no tells a woman everything about how he would take a yes.
He has no opinions

I made a new recipe one Thursday and it was not very good. Tom said so. I asked Eric and he said it was great. I pushed. He said it was interesting. I pushed again and he admitted the sauce was a little flat.
That is a small thing. But it is the same thing that happens on his dates. A woman asks where he wants to eat and he says anywhere. She asks what movie and he says whatever she likes. She asks what he thinks about something and he asks what she thinks first.
Women are not asking these questions to be polite. They are trying to find out who he is. When he gives them nothing, they have nothing to hold onto.
I told Eric that having an opinion is not the same as being pushy. He can say he would rather have Italian and still be glad to go for Mexican if she prefers. The point is that she knows there is a person in there.
A man with no opinions is hard to miss, because there was never anything there to miss.
He gets bitter and blames the women

Late in the fall, Eric said something at supper that I did not like. He said women say they want a nice guy but they really want a jerk. He said it like it was a fact.
I set down my cup. I told him that in all my years I have never met a woman who wanted to be treated badly. I have met plenty who wanted a man with a backbone. Those are not the same thing.
Tom added that every man he knows who talks that way has stopped looking at himself. It is easier to blame a whole half of the human race than to ask what you could do different.
Eric was quiet for a bit. Then he said that was fair. I give him credit for that. A lot of men never get that far.
Bitterness about women is the surest sign that the problem is not the women.
He thinks being nice is the whole offer

I asked Eric what he brings to a relationship. He said he is a nice guy. I waited. He said he is loyal. I waited some more. He did not have much else.
Being nice is the floor. It is where you start. It is not something a woman should be grateful for, any more than I should be grateful that Tom does not steal my purse.
I told him to think about what else there is. Is he interesting? Is he working on something? Does he take care of himself? Does he have friends who respect him? Those are the things a woman actually weighs.
A reader named Diane K., 59, from Spokane, Washington, said her daughter once told her that nice is what you say about a man when there is nothing else to say. I thought that was a little harsh. Then I thought about it longer and decided it was mostly right.
Nice is the price of admission. It is not the show.
He moves too slow and calls it respect
Eric went on a date in November. It went well. She laughed at his jokes and stayed for dessert. He walked her to her car and shook her hand.
Tom nearly choked on his coffee.
Eric said he did not want to be presumptuous. I asked when he planned to see her again. He said he was going to give it a week or two so she did not feel pressured. By the time he texted, she had made other plans.
I understand the fear here. He does not want to be the kind of man who pushes. Good. But there is a wide stretch of road between pushing and standing still, and a woman who had a nice evening would like to know he enjoyed it too. Waiting two weeks does not tell her he is respectful. It tells her he is not that interested.
Respect is not the same as hesitation.
He cannot take a compliment

One night I told Eric he looked sharp. He had a new shirt on. He said it was just something from the clearance rack and he did not know if it fit right and he was probably going to return it.
That is what he does on dates too. A woman says she had a good time and he says he hopes he was not boring. She says she likes his laugh and he says it is too loud.
I told him that when he bats away a compliment, he is telling the woman her judgment is wrong. She said something nice and he corrected her. That gets old fast.
Tom is not a man of many words but when I tell him he looks good he says thank you and squares his shoulders a little. That is the whole trick.
Saying thank you is enough. Anything more argues with her.
He wants credit for not being a jerk

This was the last one I figured out, and it was the hardest to say to him.
Eric told us he does not understand it. He does not cheat. He does not yell. He does not play games. He wanted to know why that was not enough.
I told him that not doing bad things is not the same as doing good things. A woman is not grading him against the worst man she ever met. She is deciding whether she wants to spend her life sitting across the table from him. The fact that he will not hurt her is wonderful. It is also the bare minimum.
He said that was a lot to take in. I told him that was fine. He had a long drive home to think about it.
A reader named Marilyn H., 66, from Montgomery, Alabama, put it simply. She said she did not marry her husband because he was not terrible. She married him because he was good company and he made her feel like herself.
A woman is not looking for a man who will not hurt her. She is looking for a man she is glad to see.
I do not know how Eric’s story turns out. He still comes on Thursdays. He is quieter now when he talks about dating, but it is a better kind of quiet. Last week he told us he asked a woman from the hardware store to dinner and she said yes. He did not shake her hand at the car. That is all he would tell us, and Tom told him that was plenty.
I want to be clear that none of this is about being less nice. The world has enough men who are not nice. It is about being more than nice. It is about being a whole person who happens to also be decent, instead of a decent person who has not figured out the rest yet.
If you have a nice young man in your life who cannot figure out why it is not working, which one of these would you tell him first?


