Ways for Men to Compliment a Woman’s Looks That She’ll Actually Appreciate
Last spring our church had its potluck on the lawn. A young man named Caleb had been coming to our table for coffee after the service…

Last spring our church had its potluck on the lawn. A young man named Caleb had been coming to our table for coffee after the service for most of the winter. He brought his girlfriend Hannah that day. She had curled her hair and worn a yellow dress I had not seen before. Caleb looked at her and said, “You look fine.” I watched her face fall about an inch. He did not notice. He went to get a plate.
I came home and wrote “you look fine” on the back of the bulletin. Then I kept writing. Tom was in his chair with the paper. He asked what I was doing. I told him I was making a list of how men should compliment a woman’s looks. He said he had been doing it for thirty years and would be glad to help. I told him I would be the judge of that.
Over the next two months I asked readers of this blog what compliments they actually remembered. The letters piled up on the kitchen table. Caleb kept coming for coffee. He did get better. Here is the list, with a little of what happened along the way.
Notice what she changed

Hannah had curled her hair for the potluck. Her hair is usually straight. Caleb did not say a word about it. The next Sunday I asked him if he knew her hair had been different. He thought about it and said maybe. I told him that maybe was the problem.
Janice R., 54, from Peoria, Illinois, wrote that she once cut six inches off her hair. Her husband did not mention it for four days. She said she would have rather he hated it than not seen it.
If she changed something, that is the thing to talk about first.
Say it before she has to ask

Tom came down the hall one morning while I was putting on earrings for a funeral. I had on the navy dress. He said, “That dress still fits you better than anything in the closet.” I had not asked. That is why it counted.
When a woman has to say “how do I look,” she already feels unsure. Whatever comes next sounds like an answer to a test.
Get there first, before she has to fish for it.
Pick one specific thing

“You look fine” could mean anything. It could mean her shoes match. It could mean she does not have spinach in her teeth. I told Caleb to pick one thing. Just one. The dress, the hair, the earrings, her eyes. I said to name it out loud.
Deb H., 61, from Bangor, Maine, wrote that her husband once told her the green scarf made her eyes look like the lake in August. She has worn that scarf for twenty years. She said she does not even like scarves.
One named detail does more than a whole sentence of general praise.
Give credit for the effort

I spent an hour on my hair for our anniversary dinner last year. Tom did not say it looked nice. He said, “You went to some trouble tonight. I can tell.” I liked that better. He saw the work, not just the result.
A woman knows how long she stood in front of the mirror. When a man sees that too, she feels like the time was worth it.
Say that you can tell she tried.
Look up when you say it

Caleb told Hannah her sweater was pretty while he was looking at his phone. She said thank you to the top of his head. I saw it happen in our kitchen. I did not say anything until he left. Then I told Tom I was adding a line about eyes.
Tom reads the paper every morning. When he has something nice to say about how I look, he folds it down first. It takes two seconds.
Put the phone down and look at her face.
Keep it to one sentence

Teresa L., 47, from Lubbock, Texas, wrote that a man she dated once gave her a compliment that lasted about a minute. He went on about her hair and her skin and her shoulders. She said by the end she felt like she was being appraised at an auction.
Tom’s best compliments are short. “That red looks good on you.” Then he goes back to whatever he was doing. It lands and he leaves it there.
One sentence, then let it sit.
Don’t tie it to a favor

Tom tried this once early on. He said I looked nice and then asked if I would call his mother for him. I remember it thirty years later. The compliment got erased by the ask.
Caleb did the same thing to Hannah at our table. He said her hair looked good and then asked if she would drive home so he could nap. She gave him a look I recognized.
If you want something, ask for it another time.
Let other people hear it

We had our oldest and the grandkids over for Sunday dinner. I had on a new blouse. Tom said, “Your mother looks good in blue, doesn’t she?” He said it to the table, not to me. Our oldest agreed. I felt about ten feet tall.
Annette W., 66, from Dubuque, Iowa, wrote that the compliments she remembers most are the ones her husband said to his friends while she was in the next room. He did not know she could hear.
A kind word said out loud in front of others carries extra weight.
Leave other women out of it

Monica S., 39, from Reno, Nevada, wrote that her boyfriend once told her she looked “so much better than his ex.” She said it ruined the whole evening. She did not want to be in a contest. She did not want to think about the ex at all.
Caleb told Hannah she looked prettier than her sister at the potluck. Hannah did not say anything. Her sister was standing about four feet away.
A compliment should be about her and nobody else.
Say it on a plain Tuesday

I was in my robe on a Tuesday morning. No makeup. Hair in a clip. I was scraping burnt toast into the sink. Tom walked by and said, “You still have the nicest neck.” Then he poured his coffee.
I have had a lot of compliments at weddings and dinners. The ones I keep are the ones from ordinary mornings. Nobody dresses up for a Tuesday. That is why it feels true.
Find something good about her on a day when nothing is going on.
Mention her face, not just the dress

Fran K., 58, from Macon, Georgia, wrote that her husband tells her the dress is nice. The shoes are nice. The purse is nice. She said she started to feel like a coat rack. She wanted him to say something about her.
I told Caleb to look above the collar. Her smile. Her eyes. The way she laughs with her whole face. Hannah has a laugh that shows every tooth. I told him to tell her he likes it.
The clothes come off at night. Compliment the part that stays.
Praise the old sweater too

I have a gray cardigan I have worn for fifteen years. The elbows are thin. I wear it to make soup. Tom said one fall evening that I looked comfortable in it and that he liked seeing me in it. He was not trying to flatter me. He meant it.
Rita B., 63, from Olympia, Washington, wrote that her husband only compliments her when she is dressed up. She said it makes her feel like the rest of the week does not count.
The clothes she wears every day deserve a word too.
Use your own words

Caleb told Hannah she was “a vision.” I asked him where he got that. He said a movie. Hannah had laughed at him, and not in a good way. He could not figure out why.
Tom has never called me a vision. He has told me I look like I slept well. He has told me my hair is doing the thing he likes. Those are his words. They sound like him.
Plain words from your own mouth beat borrowed lines.
Name the color

Most men do not notice color. The ones who do stand out. Tom knows I wear a lot of blue. He will say, “That is a good blue on you.” Sometimes it is not even blue. I correct him and we both laugh. But he tried.
Kathleen M., 52, from Scranton, Pennsylvania, wrote that her husband told her the rust-colored coat made her look warm. She went back to the store and bought the matching hat.
Say the color out loud, even if you get it a little wrong.
Notice the small things she chose

Hannah wore tiny gold hoops to the potluck. I saw them because I was looking. Caleb did not. I told him that earrings do not happen by accident. Somebody picked them out and put them on.
A woman decides on her earrings, her nail color, the clip in her hair. These are small decisions. When a man notices one, she feels like he was paying attention the whole time.
Pick out one small choice she made and tell her you saw it.
Mean it when she asks

Sometimes she will ask. “Does this look all right?” Tom used to say “yes” without looking up. I could tell. Now he looks. If it is fine, he says what is fine about it. If the hem is caught in my shoe, he says that too.
Teresa L. wrote back a second time to say that she can hear a reflex compliment from across the house. She said it sounds like a door closing.
If you say it, look first and mean it.
Bring it up again later

I wore a red coat to a Christmas party years ago. Tom said it looked good at the door. Then in the car on the way home he said, “I kept looking at you in that coat all night.” That second one is the one I remember.
The first compliment says he noticed. The second one says he kept noticing. That is a different thing.
Mention it once more when the moment has passed.
Don’t take it back with a joke

Caleb told Hannah her dress was pretty. Then he said, “Did you get it at the thrift store?” He meant it as a tease. She had gotten it at the thrift store. She did not laugh.
Some men get nervous when they say something sweet. They cover it up with a joke right after. The joke is the part she hears.
If you say something kind, let it stand without a punchline.
Send it when you’re apart

Tom does not text much. But once when I was at my sister’s for a week he sent me a message that said he missed looking at me across the table. I read it four times. I showed it to my sister. She said she might cry.
Monica S. wrote that her boyfriend sends her a line in the middle of the workday once in a while. Nothing fancy. “Thinking about your smile.” She said it changes the rest of her afternoon.
A few words from far away can mean more than a speech up close.
Let it stand on its own

Fran K. wrote one more thing in her letter. She said her husband used to only compliment her right before bed. She started to feel like it was a toll he paid. It stopped feeling like a gift.
Tom tells me I look good at breakfast. He tells me in the car. He tells me when we are raking leaves on a Saturday and I have mud on my knees. Nothing comes after it. That is why I believe him.
Say it with nothing you want on the other side of it.
By the end of summer Caleb had improved. One Sunday Hannah came in with her hair pinned up. He looked at her and said, “You pinned it up. I like that. I can see your neck.” Hannah turned pink. I looked at Tom. Tom raised his coffee cup an inch.
I do not think there is a trick to any of this. It is just paying attention and then saying what you saw. Thirty years in, that is still what works at our house. What is the one compliment someone gave you that you have never forgotten?


