The Types of Women Men Will Avoid at All Costs
The summer our youngest was away at a camp job, a young man named Wes started showing up at our back door on Sunday evenings. He…

The summer our youngest was away at a camp job, a young man named Wes started showing up at our back door on Sunday evenings. He cut lawns on our street. Tom hired him after his back gave out on the mower, and I fed him because that is what I do with anyone who stands in my kitchen long enough. Wes was twenty-six. He was polite, he ate like a horse, and by the second Sunday he was telling us about his dating life over pot roast.
He had a lot of dating life to tell about. Every few weeks there was a new name. Some of the stories were funny. Some of them made me set my fork down. Tom mostly listened and chewed and said things like “Huh” and “Well.” By August I had started writing the names of the women down on the back of a church bulletin, with a word or two next to each one about why Wes had stopped calling her.
Then I did what I have been doing for a while now on this blog. I asked the men who read here what makes them back away from a woman, and I asked them to be honest. I told them I would use their first names and the first letter of their last names. Seventy-three men wrote in. What they said lined up with Wes and his church bulletin more than I expected. Here are the seven types that came up again and again.
The woman who keeps a running tab

Wes told us about a woman named Jenna over the second Sunday supper. She was fun, he said. She was pretty. But every time he did not do something, she had a list ready. He had bought her flowers once, so why not again. He had driven to her side of town three times, so now it was her turn to be upset about it. Wes said it felt like he was always a little bit in debt and never sure how much.
Tom cut into his pot roast and said, “Did you ever pay the tab?” Wes laughed and said there was no paying it. That was the thing. The tab only went up.
Dale R., 54, from Lancaster, Pennsylvania, wrote almost the same words. He said his first wife kept score on everything from dishes to who called whose mother last. He said the worst part was that she was usually right about the count. He just could not live in a house where someone was always counting.
I will be honest. I have kept score in my own marriage. There was a stretch when the kids were small where I could have told you to the minute how much sleep Tom got compared to me. It did not make either of us happier. It made me tired and it made him careful around me, which is not the same thing as close.
A tally is not a relationship, it is an invoice.
The woman who runs tests

Somewhere in July Wes told us about a woman who went quiet on him for four days. No reason. He asked what was wrong and she said nothing. He asked again and she said if he did not know, she was not going to tell him. He eventually figured out she was upset that he had not noticed her new haircut. The haircut was about an inch shorter.
I asked him what he did. He said he apologized. Then two weeks later she told him she was going out with her girlfriends and wanted to see if he would ask her not to go. He did not ask, because why would he. That was the end of that one.
Ken W., 41, from Omaha, Nebraska, wrote that he dated a woman who would say “I’m fine” in a voice that meant the opposite, and then grade him on whether he pushed. He said he always felt like he was taking a quiz he had not studied for. He said he is now married to a woman who just tells him when she is mad, and he said it is the most restful thing in his life.
Tom read that one over my shoulder and nodded. I asked him if I ever tested him. He thought about it longer than I liked and said, “Early on. Not now.” Fair enough. I remember doing it. I remember waiting to see if he would call, and feeling like I had won something when he did. It is a strange kind of winning. You win and you still do not know if he loves you, because you set it up.
If you have to trick a man into proving something, the proof is worth nothing.
The woman who talks him down in front of people

This one came from a cookout, not from Wes. Our neighbors had a party in August and Wes came because he mows for half the street. He brought a woman named Carly. She was lively and sharp and I liked her for about twenty minutes. Then Wes told a story about getting lost on the way to a job and she said, loud enough for the whole deck to hear, “He can’t read a map, he can barely read a menu.”
Everybody laughed. Wes laughed too. But I watched his shoulders. He did not tell another story the rest of the night.
Marcus T., 36, from Raleigh, North Carolina, wrote that this was the one thing that ended it for him every time. He said he can take a woman being blunt with him in private. He said a woman who makes him the punchline in front of his friends is telling him something about how she sees him, and he has learned to believe her.
My mother had a rule about this and she said it out loud more than once. You can say anything you need to say to your husband across the kitchen table. You do not say it across the church basement. I thought it was old-fashioned when I was young. Thirty-some years in, I think it is just manners, and manners are not old-fashioned, they are just rare.
A man will forgive a lot, but he does not forget being made small in a room full of people.
The woman who has no life of her own

Wes dated a woman in June who I never met but heard plenty about. She texted him forty times a day. Not a figure of speech. He showed Tom the phone. She did not have close friends. She did not have hobbies. When he was busy she said he did not care about her, and when he was free she wanted all of it.
He said at first it felt good to be needed that much. By week three it felt like being the only pillar holding up a porch.
Phil D., 63, from Duluth, Minnesota, has been married twice and said the difference between the two marriages was exactly this. His first wife wanted him to be her whole world. His second wife had a book club, a sister she called every Sunday, and a garden she loved more than she loved him some weeks. He said he would take the garden every time. He said a woman who is already full is a woman who is choosing you, not clinging to you.
I think about this one a lot now that the house is quiet. When the kids left, I had to go find my own life again. I had let a lot of it go. Tom did not say anything about it, but I could feel him waiting to see what I would do with the time. I am glad I did not hand it all to him. He has his leaves to rake. I have my own things. We are better at supper because of it.
A woman with her own life gives a man room to want her instead of just carrying her.
The woman who is still at war with her ex

In early July Wes stopped seeing a woman named Dana after three dates. I asked why, because the first two had sounded good. He said her ex came up on every date. Not in passing. In detail. What the ex did, what the ex said, what the ex’s new girlfriend looked like, what she would do if she saw the ex at the grocery store.
Wes said he could not tell if she was done with the man or still auditioning for him.
Curtis B., 47, from Tulsa, Oklahoma, wrote that he is divorced himself and has no problem with a woman having a past. He said the problem is when the past is still sitting in the chair between them at dinner. He said anger is a kind of attachment, and he does not want to date a woman who is still attached to somebody else, even if what she is attached to is hating him.
I have a sister. She has said some things about an old boyfriend that I will not repeat here. It took her a long time to stop. The man she eventually married was patient about it, but he told her once, plainly, that he could not compete with a ghost. She stopped after that. I think she had not realized how much air she was giving the ghost.
A man cannot build anything with a woman whose heart is still busy with the last fight.
The woman who is never the one who is wrong

This one is the one Tom wanted me to write about. He said so. We were sitting on the porch after Wes left one Sunday and Tom said, “Put the one in who never says sorry.” I asked which one that was, because Wes had told us about a few. He said, “Any of them. All of them. It’s the same one.”
Wes had a woman in his phone who, by his telling, had never once in two months admitted a mistake. If she was late, traffic. If she snapped at him, he had provoked her. If she forgot his birthday, he should have reminded her. Wes said it was not that any one of those things was a big deal. It was that he could see the whole shape of the next ten years and he was always going to be the one apologizing.
Jim H., 58, from Billings, Montana, said he was married to this for nineteen years. He said the marriage did not end over one big fight. He said it ended because he realized he had never heard the words “I was wrong” from her, not once, and he had said them hundreds of times. He said the imbalance wore a groove in him.
I will tell you that I am not naturally good at this one. I like being right. Tom will tell you I like being right. But I learned somewhere in the second decade that saying “I was wrong about that” costs me about five seconds and buys me a husband who is not braced against me. That is a good trade. I would make it every day.
A woman who cannot say sorry is asking a man to be the only one who ever bends.
The woman who expects him to guess

The last name on my church bulletin was a woman Wes saw in late August, right before he went back to school. He liked her a lot. He told us that on the last Sunday with real feeling. But she had a habit of wanting things and never saying what they were. She wanted him to plan a certain kind of date, but she would not tell him which kind. She wanted a certain gift, but she said he should just know. When he guessed wrong, which was most of the time, she was hurt, and the hurt was somehow proof that he did not know her.
Tom said, “Son, I have been married more than thirty years and I still cannot read Linda’s mind.” I said that was true and that I had quit expecting it around year five.
Andre L., 33, from Tampa, Florida, wrote the longest letter of the seventy-three. He said he grew up with a mother who said exactly what she wanted, and he thought all women did that. Then he dated a woman who treated every plain request like it ruined the magic. He said he spent a year guessing and failing, and it made him feel stupid, and he is not stupid. He said he now tells women on the first date that he will do almost anything they ask, but they have to ask.
Here is what I have figured out at my own kitchen table. Saying what you want is not unromantic. It is just efficient. Tom brings me the flowers I like because I told him which ones. He makes the coffee the way I take it because I told him once and he remembered. None of that is less sweet for being clear. It is sweeter, because he gets it right.
A man cannot give you what you want if you make him guess what it is.
Wes went back to school the first week of September. He sent Tom a text about the mower before he left and a second text to me that just said thanks for the pot roast. I folded up the church bulletin and put it in the drawer with the rubber bands and the dead batteries, which is where important paper goes in this house.
I want to be plain about something before I close. Every type on this list has a male version. Men keep score. Men run tests. Men talk their wives down at cookouts, and I have watched it happen on that same deck. I wrote this one for women because the men wrote to me, but if you flipped every one of these around, it would still be true. Nobody wants to be counted, tested, mocked, smothered, compared to a ghost, blamed, or made to guess. That is not a man thing. That is a person thing.
I also want to say that I have been several of these women. Not all at once, I hope. But I kept score for a few years, and I tested Tom when I was young, and I am still working on the saying sorry part. Nobody is born knowing how to be easy to love. You learn it, usually from somebody who is patient with you while you are still bad at it.
Which one of these seven have you caught yourself being, and what helped you stop?


