Reasons Why Good Women Often End Up Alone
My friend Bev showed up on a Tuesday in January with a loaf of banana bread and a question. She set the bread on my counter,…

My friend Bev showed up on a Tuesday in January with a loaf of banana bread and a question. She set the bread on my counter, sat down at the kitchen table, and asked me why she was still alone. She was not crying. She was not angry. She just wanted to know.
Bev is in her fifties. She has been divorced a long time. She shows up for everyone. She drives people to the doctor. She remembers birthdays. She is the kind of woman you want on your side when things fall apart. And she has spent most of the last twenty years sleeping on one side of a queen bed.
I told her I did not know. Then I spent about a month trying to find out. I watched Bev. I watched the single women at church and at the library and at the grocery store. I asked readers of this blog to write in about their own lives. Tom listened to me read the letters at supper and gave me his two cents. This is what I came up with. None of it is meant as blame. It is just what I noticed.
She gives everything away before anyone asks

Bev went on two dates with a man from her church last spring. Two. By the third week she was driving his mother to her eye appointments. She baked for his grandson’s school thing. She reorganized his pantry because he mentioned once that he could never find the oatmeal.
He did not ask for any of that. He did not need to. She saw a gap and she filled it. That is who she is. It is why her friends love her.
The man drifted off by June. When I asked Bev what happened, she said he told her it felt like a lot. She was hurt by that. I understood why. But I also thought about what it must have felt like from his chair. He went on two dates and came home to a woman who had already moved into the corners of his life.
A reader named Sharon K., 57, from Dubuque, Iowa, wrote me something that stuck. She said she used to treat every new man like a house she was fixing up. She would get all the work done in the first month. Then there was nothing left to do, and nothing left to want.
Here is the plain truth. A man cannot miss you if you never leave him room to.
She waits to be chosen

There was a church supper in February. Bev worked the kitchen most of the night. When she finally came out, she stood by the coffee urn with her hands folded. There was a widower there named Doug. Nice man. He had asked about her twice that I know of. She knew it too. She stood by the coffee and smiled at the room and waited.
He did not come over. He was shy too. Two shy people in one church hall is a long evening with nothing to show for it.
I asked Bev why she did not walk across the room. She said that was not how she was raised. The man is supposed to do the walking. I was raised the same way, so I did not argue. But I did point out that she had crossed that room fifty times to refill the creamer. She could cross it once to say hello.
Tom said something at supper that night that I think was right. He said most men over fifty are not brave. They were brave once, at twenty, and it got them a divorce or a funeral. Now they wait for a sign. If a good woman never gives one, they assume there is none to give.
Waiting feels like patience, but sometimes it is just hiding.
She mistakes being needed for being loved

A reader from Macon, Georgia, named Teresa L., 61, told me about a man she saw for three years. He called her when his sink backed up. He called her when his daughter needed a ride. He called her when his dog died. He did not call her on Saturdays.
Teresa said it took her the full three years to notice the pattern. She was always on his list of people to call. She was never the first call, and never the one that was just to talk.
Bev has done a version of this. More than once. A man leans on her. She feels useful. Useful feels warm. She mistakes the warmth for something it is not. Then the man gets back on his feet and goes looking for someone who was not there for the hard part.
I have been married more than thirty years, and I will say this. Tom needs me plenty. But that is not why he stays. He stays because he likes me at the table. If he only wanted a nurse and a ride, he could hire both.
Being needed is a job. Being wanted is a relationship.
She will not settle, and she is right not to

This one is different from the rest. It is not a mistake. I want to say that clearly.
Bev had coffee with a man last fall who talked for ninety minutes and never asked her a question. Not one. She came to my house after and I expected her to be discouraged. Instead she was calm. She said she would rather eat dinner alone with a book than eat dinner with someone who did not notice she was there.
I thought about that for a long time. A lot of women Bev’s age are not alone. They are married to men who talk for ninety minutes and never ask a question. They made their peace with it at thirty and now they are sixty. I am not judging them. I am only saying that some of the women who end up alone got there because they refused to do that.
Marianne D., 59, from Spokane, Washington, wrote me a short note. She said her mother told her at twenty that a bad husband is lonelier than an empty house. She said she did not believe it until she had tried both.
Being alone because you held out is not a failure. It is a cost, and some women decide it is worth paying.
She stays loyal to the wrong one too long

Before Doug and the church suppers, there was a man Bev saw on and off for nine years. I will not say his name because he still lives around here. He never once called her his girlfriend. He said he was not ready. He said it at year one, and year four, and year eight.
Bev stayed. She stayed because leaving felt like giving up, and giving up felt like something a lesser woman would do. Good women finish what they start. That is the story she told herself.
A reader named Carla M., 55, from Wichita, Kansas, told me nearly the same story with a different man. Ten years. She said the hardest part was realizing that her loyalty was the thing keeping her stuck. The very quality she was proudest of was the one he was using.
When Bev finally ended it, the man was remarried within eighteen months. To a woman he had known for one year. That was the thing that broke her a little. He was ready. He had just never been ready for her.
Loyalty to someone who will not commit is not loyalty. It is a long goodbye you keep refusing to say.
She is so capable that no one thinks she needs anyone

In March, Bev’s gutter came loose in a windstorm. Tom drove over to help. By the time he got there she had the ladder out and the thing reattached. He stood in the driveway holding his drill and she waved at him from the roof.
He came home and told me that, and we laughed. But then he said something else. He said if he were a single man, he would not know where he fit in Bev’s life. She does her own taxes. She changes her own oil. She fixed her own furnace two winters ago with a video and a flashlight.
None of that is wrong. I am glad she can do it. But I think it sends a signal she does not mean to send. It says she has it handled. A lot of men hear that and decide they are not needed. And men, for whatever reason, need to feel needed a little bit. Not a lot. A little.
I asked Bev when she last let a man carry something for her. She thought about it and could not come up with a time. She said it felt silly to pretend she could not lift a bag of mulch. I said it was not about the mulch.
Letting someone help you is not weakness. It is an invitation, and some people are waiting for one.
She is harder on herself than anyone else ever would be

The last scene is from April. Bev had a date with Doug. He finally came over to her at a potluck and asked. They went to a fish fry and it was fine. Not fireworks. Fine.
She came to my kitchen afterward and sat down and took it apart piece by piece. She talked too much about her sister. She laughed at something that was not funny. She ordered the wrong thing. She wore the blue sweater and should have worn the green one. Forty minutes of this.
I asked her what Doug did wrong. She looked at me like I had asked something strange. She said he was fine. Then she went back to the sweater.
I have watched Bev do this after every date for years. Each one becomes a list of her own errors. She never puts a single mark in the other column. By the time the next date comes around, she walks in already convinced she is going to ruin it.
Tom said it best, and I will let him have the last word on this one. He said a woman who is grading herself all night is not really at the table. She is in the back of the room with a clipboard.
If you spend the whole evening judging yourself, there is no room left to enjoy anyone else.
Bev and Doug have been out four more times since that fish fry. She still comes over after. She still mentions the sweater sometimes. But last week she told me he had asked three questions about her sister and seemed to want the answers. She said it like it surprised her. I told her that was the whole point.
I do not think Bev is alone because something is wrong with her. I think she is alone because she is generous to a fault, patient past the point of sense, and twice as hard on herself as she is on anyone else. Those are good qualities. They just need a little steering.
Which of these have you seen in a good woman you know, or in yourself?


